Literary Agent
Cara Stout @CaraFoshizzle
What makes you fall in love with a manuscript enough to off rep? #askPSLAI love this question--and there are so many answers! For me, it's:
- great writing
- characters I can't get enough of
- interesting plot
- genre I'm interested in
- feels fresh (can be a classic trope, but shouldn't feel stale)
Could go on forever! #askPSLA
Literary Agent
Carly Vair @cnvair
Okay, this one has been killing me lately: Is pitching a novella a waste of time? Is there a market for them? It seems like a new one comes out every week (especially SF/F), but all the advice I've seen basically amounts to "don't bother pitching a novella." #askPSLAMy advice in the novella space is always to pitch agents who have worked on the novellas you’ve been picking up. Particularly in that SFF space.
Not a lot of folks work on them, but some certainly do. #askPSLA
Literary Agent
Catherine Burgess @GattaScrive
Several articles and people suggest writers should query 80-100 agents, but that they should all be agents you have extensively researched and thought you would be a good fit for each other. What advice would you have to balance these two seemingly opposing ideas? #askPSLAI recommend researching agents before submitting to them, but make that wishlist and prioritize. To make it a little less overwhelming, you could submit to agents in waves. Also, keep in mind you might not know if an agent is really a good fit until you speak with them. #askPSLA
Literary Agent
Ashley McAnelly @ashewriter
Honestly, how do you balance write time/agent time with parent life because I need that secret now. #askPSLAMy son is trying to eat my mail right now so perhaps I’m not the best person to answer this. #askPSLA
But really, industry friends trying to juggle it all? Group messages with my colleagues going through the same helps. ❤️
Literary Agent
Nick Sweeney @NickMakesIllos
@PSLiterary @ericsmithrocks @claire_m_harris What makes you give a no with some feedback vs. a no from a generic form letter? #askPSLAI generally don't have time to give feedback unless I'm asking to take a look at a revised version. It's a hard balance because we want to help, but we also get so many queries and giving everyone feedback wouldn't be a good use of our time as agents. #askPSLA
Literary Agent
Eilene Spear @EileneSpear
Sorry if I’m asking too many questions, but I’d appreciate your thoughts on prologues in general? Any red flags? #askPSLANo apologies, we are here for it!
I like a good prologue. The only time I can’t stand them is when it’s a character looking back. “Now I’ll tell you my story.”
Well, they turned out okay, so... why read the book? Try not to let your prologue ruin your stakes. #askPSLA
Literary Agent
Sky Regina 🏳️🌈🦇🍁 @SkyFrizzle
@PSLiterary @ericsmithrocks @claire_m_harris Any specific red flags that make you stop reading first pgs? Perhaps overdone clichés? #askPSLAOverdone cliches, yes, but also writing that I don't connect with, confusing plot right off the bat, too many characters being introduced in quick succession (but without being able to distinguish between them). #askPSLA
Literary Agent
Eilene Spear @EileneSpear
I am ready to query, but I know my title is awful! Is that a showstopper? #askPSLADefinitely not a showstopper, it's something agents can help you tweak (and editors are commonly thinking of new titles, as well). #askPSLA
Literary Agent
Kate @cummingsgoings
@PSLiterary @ericsmithrocks @claire_m_harris What's the sweet spot for nonfic book proposal length? How many sample chapters do you like to see?This is a good question that I can actually fish resources for! I have three full non fiction proposals here. ericsmithrocks.com/perfect-pitch
I tend to ask for 5k to 10k in terms of sample pages. #askPSLA
Literary Agent
Michelle Wangsgard @m_wangsgard
#askPSLAHi there!
How do you personally (and/or as an agent) know when a project is ready for querying? I know it’s when you feel it’s the best it could be, but is there anything specific you do or feel or look for??
Thanks so much for doing this ☺️!
You want your project to be in good shape, of course. But if it gets to the point where you're only making one-word tweaks here and there, I'd say it's time. Make sure you have someone else read for plot holes, too. #askPSLA
Literary Agent
Eilene Spear @EileneSpear
I am ready to query, but I know my title is awful! Is that a showstopper? #askPSLANope! So many titles change from agent to editor to publication.
You should still have a title that you’re proud to shop your book around under though. #askPSLA
Literary Agency
For more about Hannah and what she's looking for, check out this #askagent interview that she did with @bluepencil_edit earlier this year: bluepencilagency.com/ask-an-agent-h…
Literary Agent
Answering #askagent questions tomorrow and my animals will be making appearances. Here’s the link instagram.com/stories/sztown…
Literary Agent
Hannah Weatherill @hgweatherill
Some brilliant advice from my colleague @lorna_colwill on researching agents and cover letters! twitter.com/NorthbankTalen…Also, if you have a novel ready to submit, please do send it our way! See northbanktalent.com/contact for submission guidelines 📚📝
#amquerying #MSWL #askagent
Literary Agent
KC Schreiber @Kranky_Crow
@UweStenderPhD At what point in a requested ms do you throw in the towel? And what makes you refer the writer to one of your colleagues at the agency, rather than just giving a final “no”?When you are out of all legitimate agents to query to.
If I think it is good, but may work better for them than me.
Literary Agent
Ann Dayleview @AnnDayleview
@UweStenderPhD Hi there I'm wondering about MG and if you should do multi POV or is it best to just stick to one? #askagentThat depends on whether you can pull off more than one uniquely identifiable voice.
Literary Agent
Lynn Hooghiemstra @Nicky_Adams_Pen
@UweStenderPhD I see books coming out on WWII, but mine is struggling to find a home, perhaps follows history too closely and doesn't have a specific hook (tattooist of Auschwitz, dressmaker of Auschwitz, etc.) for US audiences? In many ways it mirrors what we're seeing in US today. Thoughts?I think you may be right. But, in general, historical fiction can be tough in and by itself.
Literary Agent
Jerome Abalone @JeromeAbalone
@UweStenderPhD Is it ever acceptable to resubmit to an agent who rejected a query or never replied? In particular, after thorough revisions (e.g. the agent has not seen the new opening chapters before and the tone of the story has changed significantly)I would. If they don't respond at all and/or don't give you a reason, like an out of office message that details reasons for a no response, you have no idea if they received it or not.
Literary Agent
Alan @WondrousPity
@UweStenderPhD Hello! I was wondering if there are any little things authors can do to help your process in reading queries and pages beyond following submission guidelines and doing as the agent asks? Hope you have a nice day!Thank you, I hope you are having a good day. Hmm, I think you pretty much covered it. Yes, I can't think of anything else.