Literary Agent
Vince Adams @VinceAdams19
@annmrose Hi Ann, thanks for your availability. I’m finishing the third book in a possible trilogy first (modern day events) then planning to complete the two chronologically earlier books afterwards. They can each stand on their own. Do you see any marketability issues with this plan?So book three comes first? Not sure I understand, but if the books stand alone then you should be okay. I would hesitate to finish all the books in that world in case it doesn't sell though. Spreading out your eggs instead of having them all in one basket isn't always a bad thing
Literary Agent
Sharon McDonell 🏳️🌈 (they/them/she/her) @1LesbianOutLoud
@annmrose #askagent Should I include comps when they’re not spot on~in space vs grounded, near future vs centuries away?Just say how they are a comp. For example, the family dynamics of X Title, is a way to explain how the book you've chosen makes it a great comp. Make sense?
Literary Agent
Anna Maria Ball @AnnaMBwrites
@annmrose Would you want to know in the pitch letter if the author is neurodivergent?If that is something you want to share. But it's not required for any author to self disclose anything they aren't comfortable sharing.
Literary Agent
STEPHANIE L WARD @StephaineWard
@annmrose Do you like reading about the story or comps and word count first in a query?It doesn't make a difference to me.
Literary Agent
Casey Kincade @Noir_Kincade
@annmrose Thank you for answering all these questions!I’m seeing a lot of agents who are not accepting dystopian and post-apocalyptic fiction. Is this a trend that you’re seeing from the inside as well? Seems like a hard time to get traction with those sub-genres.
I don't see many editors actively seeking this right now, which is why agents might not be open to it. That doesn't mean if it is done well it won't find it's home though, so don't be discouraged.
Literary Agent
Michaelina Deneka @M_Deneka
@annmrose Would you prefer that we specify when we’ve borrowed elements from a subgenre our book doesn’t fully fit (e.g. “upper MG contemporary fantasy with a dark fantasy-inspired antagonist”) or just leave it at the narrowest category it fully fits (e.g. “upper MG contemporary fantasy”)?I don't think you need to be that specific
Literary Agent
Ambrielle Butler @AJButlerWriting
@annmrose How do agents feel about authors who are wanting to write across genres? Is that a dealbreaker?Not at all. The trick sometimes is finding an agent that does all those genres. Sometimes that also means having multiple agents. But it's not impossible.
Literary Agent
David Clark @Ricevillage
@annmrose I have a novel ms. I'm convinced is little like any other, so no comps I can determine. Does this mean it will be a marketing disaster?How so? A book in any genre will adhere to those conventions--romances have a HEA or HFN, a mystery will always have, well, a mystery to solve etc. So how is it different from all the other books it would sit next to on the shelf? It can't sit on it's very own shelf.
Literary Agent
Mire Marke @MireMarke
@annmrose Hi!! Is it concerning if an agent takes a long time with a full? I’ve been told that agents know pretty quickly into an ms if they love it or not. It scares me when I see an agent offered days after getting the full when I’ve got quite a few out for some time nowI don't think so. It's about bandwidth more than anything. Sometimes they really WANT to read it but they just haven't had the time. I wouldn't let length of time indicate excitement about a project. We all only have so many hours a day, and we are doing our best.
Literary Agent
Carly C'de Baca @carlycdebaca
@annmrose I heard a lot of agents don’t even look at the pages requested and go solely off the query. I understand the importance of a solid query, but what if that’s a struggle whereas the pages shine way brighter and they never give them a chance?This is always challenging for sure. All I can say is that if it's something I rep, I always look at pages because I know how hard that query is. I would only not read pages if it is clearly something I've stated I do not rep--screen plays, memoir, picture books...
Literary Agent
Christiana Doucette @doucette515
@annmrose How do you feel about middle grade novel-in-verse?I'm totally open to it. I love novels in verse.
Literary Agent
ᗩᖇTY (Taylor's version) @CuriousArtemis
@annmrose Thanks for doing this! 😊💗1. Are you seeing any sub-genre trends in adult fantasy? 2. Can crossover go from adult to YA or is that not a thing?Aside from fantasy all starting with some kind of chase scene (or running) recently, I can't think of any trends.
Yes, I think crossover can mean both ways. YA to adult or vice versa.
Literary Agent
Rebecca Weber @RWeberWrites
@annmrose If an author publishes their debut with a micro press, would agents see the debut as a pro or con to signing a future work?It just means you aren't necessarily a "debut" anymore is all. So it just means a different approach will be needed.
Literary Agent
erin @erin_go_lightly
@annmrose Should a new writer look for agents w successful, big-name clients, or would they get lost in the shuffle? Versus a newer agent / smaller agency with less clients and therefore more time to focus on you? (Con: they don't have best-sellers or big names on their resumes). Thanks!Like you said there are pros and cons to both. The best thing is to find the right person for you and your book. Sometimes that is a new eager agent where you get to be the big fish in their small pond. Sometimes that's a bigger agent and you are a little fish.
Literary Agent
Kelsey Knowles 🏳️🌈 @_Kelsey_Knowles
@annmrose When you request a full, about what % of those get an offer of rep? I know it varies from agent to agent.PS: Queried you in November and hoping to hear back soon 😊💕
My goal is to try to keep those statistics this year. I have no way of knowing at this point since we don't use Query Manager which does all that wonderful math for you.
Literary Agent
Heidi Nickerson @HeidiANickerson
@annmrose Thanks for hosting this! Obviously this can vary, but do you and/or Prospect Agency have a standard timeframe for reviewing queries? I couldn’t find a specific timeframe on the agency’s submission page.It's buried on our FAQ page... basically it is 3 months.
You aren't the first who couldn't find it though, so no worries. ❤️
Literary Agent
Michael Gilroy is querying @VanguardsMike
@annmrose How long does it take you to get through a standard query, and how many can you do in a normal day? (I know this’ll vary from person to person, but I’m still curious)On average I spend 40 hours a month going through queries. So an entire work week is basically just this on top of all the other things I do.
Literary Agent
🌋❄N.K. Valek🌱🌌 (she/her) @AfterEpilogue
@annmrose What is your recommendation for querying with a debut book that is also a first in the series?For instance, what to say in the query letter?
My recommendation is to make sure it stands alone. When querying a series you aren't saying I am hopeful you can sell this one book, you are saying I'm hoping you can sell ALL OF THESE BOOKS--and that is a huge ask.
So 'stand alone with series potential' is best.
Literary Agent
David Neuner @david_neuner
@annmrose Thank you so much for offering your time for an #askagent a session.What advice do you have for querying after the holidays when many agents are reopening to querying? Is this a bad time or a good time to query?
The best time to query is when your project is ready. If the agent is open, send it, and they will get to it when they can. There is no way to predict the exact right moment to query any one agent.
Literary Agent
Judith L Webster @JudithLWebster
@annmrose Do you expect manuscripts to be “90% polished” (I keep hearing this expectation on podcasts) when they first come to you? Or are you looking for the hook and storyline to grab your attention since it will go through professional editing anyways?I expect it to be the best you can make it, and formatted correctly.
If it's full of spelling and grammar issues that is a red flag. But a "of" instead of "for" here or there isn't a make it or break it.